30 Jan

The question “What is religion?” is unanswerable for many scholars and adherents, according to William Cavanaugh. He finds that more often than not, people will avoid the question or provide answers riddled with inaccuracies. Cavanaugh admits that religion has “fuzzy edges”, but uses this point to give reasons for why it should not be considered inherently violent (3). He points out what religion is not more than giving an explicit definition of what it is. More than anything, he pushes us to realize that the bad things we attribute to religion, such as war and unnecessary violence, are results of other idealized institutions like American patriotism. Today, people consider religion to be many things, and usually anything that helps us answer our “ultimate” questions. Religion is the vehicle many people use to discover the deepest truths about reality. While it is true that it often takes the form of a set of beliefs, a religion is the expression of one’s use of faith and reason together. It sums up all of other inquiries under one overarching discipline. A religion gives people a reason for every other pursuit in life. In many instances, one’s religion aids them in their pursuit of God or any higher power which is outside of this world. Religion guides people’s moral compasses, and instructs them on how to make ethical decisions. For example, Cavadini explains how the Catholic Church’s “‘preferential option for the poor'” is rooted primarily in a belief in God, not particularly based in a doctrine about the poor. Religion is a problem for many people because in most cases it calls us to radically transform one’s life. As a result, society is quick to blame religion for its ills, even if other institutions should be held responsible.

3 thoughts on “30 Jan

  1. I would disagree about the cause of discontent surrounding religiosity– I think people are not afraid of radical transformation, but of radical transformation being forced upon them, not of their own volition, which is the case in many religious based disputes. Also, it’s important to note that religion superseded all other institutions and therefore, whether explicitly or implicitly, plays a role in actors such as the nation and the state as entities.

    Like

  2. I was really intrigued by your comment about how we use religion to “discover the deepest truths about reality.” This really reminded me of what we talked about last lecture, especially with the concept of faith seeking understanding. By using religion and its combination of faith and reason, we are able to get farther than we could with reason alone.

    Like

  3. I agree with just about every claim that you make in this reflection. You clearly stated why religion is often held more accountable for violence and trauma than it should be. I also like how you tied religion into theology by bringing up how faith needs to seek understanding.

    Like

Leave a reply to snelson23 Cancel reply

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started